Contains spoilers

Adventure Time TV show poster

Adventure Time · S4E26

By Merrick · 3.5/5

Please Don't Be a Multiverse Thing

Summary — The Lich wears Billy's body in a season finale that's all setup and unanswered questions — and the portal tease points toward a multiverse direction that worries me more than it excites me.

A season finale that's almost all setup, and it leaves you with a pile of questions. Billy is back — or something wearing Billy is. The Lich has taken his body, and we don't actually know if the real Billy is dead or alive. Whoever's hanging out in that cave clearly isn't him: he doesn't care about all that treasure, he cares about dominion, like any lich.

The questions just stack up. The star gem they took from Lumpy Space Princess doesn't seem to be a real gemstone — it doesn't fit into the book — and it's unclear whether she even got it back. When the Lich goes through the portal, nobody helps Finn and Jake grab him: the palace was clearly alerted, and not a single banana guard shows up. Also, Finn didn't need to draw on the Ice King's face like that. It's just rude.

Finn and Jake are trusting people, and it peeves me when someone exploits that — which is the whole engine of this episode. And I don't even know how you'd stop a lich; presumably you have to destroy wherever his soul is kept, and the episode isn't interested in that question yet.

My real concern is the tease at the end: a Finn with a robotic arm, a Jake who's just an ordinary dog, the Lich stepping into some multidimensional thing. If this is heading toward a multiverse storyline, I don't like that trope — I didn't like it in Marvel, I didn't like it in Rick and Morty. It makes every decision feel inconsequential: you can make a giant change with absolutely no consequences, and then what are you even watching? So instead of getting me excited for next season, the ending introduced downside risk. We'll buckle our seatbelts and see what happens.

Judged on its own, it's a three-and-a-half: a lot of machinery being put in place, and nothing has come of any of it yet.